Imaginary Rules
Multi-site, Parent Church Stories, Philosphy of Church Multiplication, Church Planters | Email This Post February 12th, 2009by Steve Pike, National Director, AG Church Multiplication Network
Yesterday, I had a conversation that reminded me of a myth that all too often impedes the progress of starting new churches. I’ve actually heard the myth recounted several different ways. Some call it the “Five Mile Rule.” For others it’s the “Twelve Mile Rule.” I’ve even heard a variation called the “Fifty Mile Rule.” The essence of the myth is that somewhere in the official Constitution and Bylaws of the Assemblies of God there is a clause that prohibits a new church from starting up within a certain distance of an existing church. This is simply not true. Such a restriction does not exist in the General Council Constitution and By-laws. The “_________ Mile Rule” is imaginary.
The problem is that this imaginary rule has been repeated so often that a lot of leaders make decisions based on it. A lot of planters decide not to plant in a particular location because they think an existing church has “dibs” on that community. Many pastors of existing churches have appealed to the “rule” to prevent a new church from starting up near them.
In fairness, there are some Districts that do have such guidelines in their official documents… so in those Districts the rule is not imaginary. But, an increasing number of Districts are choosing to line up their official stance on the matter with the posture modeled by the General Council.
And the lack of a mileage guideline should not be construed to mean that churches should be planted without input from churches that already have ministry presence in that community. Leaders of existing churches should be part of the conversation regarding the need for a new church in the community they serve.
The needs and opportunities in America are too great for us to allow them to be hindered by imaginary rules. Before you make a decision about planting or supporting the start up of a new church in your area, make sure you have your facts straight! Too many American lives are at stake to let imaginary rules to hinder the progress of God’s Church!
Don’t hesitate to call your support team at the Church Multiplication Network. We can help you sort through the maze of organizational guidelines and find the straightest path to fulfilling what God has called you to do. Our contact number is 800-447-0427. We’re here to help.

February 12th, 2009 at 1:29 pm
Steve I just wanted you to know that this was a huge topic of conversation in our section when we planted. Our section committee had a meeting and it was brought up that we should be five miles away and we were only going to be three. When we openly discussed what our plan was and how we were going to be reaching the people in our target group then all was well. The point I am trying to make is we need to work as a body. If God is in it which he is in Church planting for sure. Then we need to be open to his leading. I think it would be good for all the Pastors to read this blog. It’s about the Kingdom!!!
Thanks
Daniel LeRoy
February 12th, 2009 at 5:39 pm
Funny, I don’t see ANYTHING in the bible about mileage rules. That seems to be the problem when we go from relationship to religion. We add rules that aren’t even in the “rule” book.
j
February 13th, 2009 at 4:19 pm
Steve,
These imaginary rules arise from real fears in Pastors hearts. It takes a lot of courage to bless new churches when they move in close. We are working on a community coalition to plant 10 churches this year, and the fears in the room are palpable when we talk about it. Pastor talk about how “hurt” they are when someone plants a church in their block without consulting them! It is as if they want a person to get permission before even witnessing to a neighbor. It is a spirit of control which is actually fear. We need a lot of encouragement to do the right things even when we are fearful.
February 14th, 2009 at 9:27 am
Gerry, I appreciate your comments… I’ve heard great stuff about your community coalition. I think the community collaboration approach is outstanding. Thanks for pioneering a path for the rest of us to follow!
February 16th, 2009 at 9:32 pm
Perhaps the case may be that the pastor opposed to a new church in his area has not given everything HE has to help the Lord build his current pastorate [except the LORD build the house!] and is fearful not only of losing his flock but perhaps being “shown up” by the new church doing what he SHOULD have been doing all along! Pastors, what would YOU do if a new church started up? Are you doing all you can with a vision and guidance from Him who called you!? Be faithful, fervent and earnest! God bless!
February 19th, 2009 at 7:29 pm
Steve, My wife and I planted a church in our city 14 years ago and we were told by friends in our District that there was a two mile rule between churchs. Unfortunatly we ended up planting our church about four miles out of town because we were not really sure of how close we should be to our sister churches.
It all worked out and we are blessed regardless but I wanted to thank you for this blog. I hope it helps others when they plant. Blessings.